L'Oreal Paris Infallible Eye Silkissime Eyeliner, Charcoal

from Jenno32

I didn't get one use out of this. I went to put it on and the makeup broke off. I tried to twist more up and it wouldn't budge. I twisted forever before giving up and throwing it out because I lost...

from MerceeMe

My only positive review is that the pencil is very soft and dark, which is my preference. My negative reviews: By the third usage I had to sharpen the pencil. Sharpening the pencil was disastrous. ...

from disadventurer

Purchased this as well and thought it was only me. It was fine until it needed to be sharpened. Same thing happened to me. Sharpened and hurt my eye. Why not make it twist up or enclose a prod...

from Jane

Not worth the money. Glides on smoothly but the amount of product you actually get will on do a couple of applications. I've only used this once. Look at pic.

from LunagShane

It won't sharpen, the twist bit at the bottom does nothing. I've tried twisting it. Both ways, over an hour and still no eyeliner. It didn't have a tip or anything on it when I bought it. Very much...