Hard Candy Walk the Line Liquid Eyeliner, 1252 Ash, 0.13 fl oz

from Makemeupinside

This is my favorite eyeliner. I love the color and it doesn't seem like it's going to be carried at Walmart anymore. I've actually heard rumors that Hard Candy won't be carried at Walmart anymore at all.

from LilyArdor

I'm don't usually write reviews but this one is worth a review. I've tried so many highend eye eyeliners and this one doesn't compare anywhere close to highend. The finish is matt. So it's not shiny when your in the sun and half your eyeball looks like there's no eyeliner and it doesn't come off ...

from Annoyed

I have used several colors of this brand and absolutely love the new Ash color. It lasts all day, easy to apply, and does not smudge. I do wish Walmart still carried this product in stores and not just online.

from Happy

I love the ash color, it is not that dramatic and yet your eyes can look nice with this color, love it. I love everything about this product.

from SedonaDonna

I ordered the Java Eyeliner and it is more a grey tone than brown. Also, I don't like waterproof eyeliner because it is too hard to remove. This was not marked waterproof, but it was very hard to remove even with eye makeup remover - actually harder than some waterproof eyeliners that I have u...