from Tinkerbell

Directions included milk. The liquid made the two top layers runny. It was messy!!

from kminlv68

Zero stars!! Whomever composed the directions on the box DID NOT state that the peanut butter filling doesn't get baked along with the cookie base and need to be done separately. What a waste of money, ended up in the garbage!! Baked some from scratch and were excellent unlike the Betty Crocker ...

from jaydee

It did not set right, both the chocolate and peanut butter were runny. So that mixed with the very sweet and weird salty taste made for a terrible dessert! The no bake reeses dessert bars are much better, get those instead if you want a really good treat.

from JeanneMcG

This product is TERRIBLE! Followed the directions and both the peanut butter layer and the chocolate layer never hardened at all and were nothing but a runny mess! In an attempt to salvage it I refrigerated it to no avail - still runny and wet. There must be something missing as I can't imagine...

from Sweetsntreats

This is sooo good! Every time I go to Walmart I buy at least two boxes. My neighbors absolutely love when I make it. My daughter and I are the only sweet freaks in the house. I will say though, I only use unsalted butter, so that may be why they always turn out amazing. To those who are saying it...