from Disappointed

You have changed the cookie by changing the cookie shape and the new cookie is rock hard and tastes like cardboard and breaks away from the filling at the slightest touch. I can't believe you ruined the best cookie you ever offered. I am no longer a customer.

from Chris

These cookies ARE NOT THE SAME, not even close. They have changed the recipe and the biscuit mow tastes like a hard tasteless outer shell. So sad!,, I loved the old recipe _ I WONT BE BUYING THESE EVER AGAIN. Not a fan of the “new” shape, I.e. recipe. They say on the package it's the same rec...

from 3timesoccermom

I hadn't had any of these in years and recently saw them on the site while browsing for something else. I was so excited to order and reminisce on how good they were. I was bitterly disappointed. For starters, the "cream filling" is now very, very thin and they are so stingy with it it doesn't e...

from Sandy

Mother's Taffy cookies have been my favorite cookie for so many years. I reluctantly purchased the new version, seeing clearly from the packaging that they're not the same. Sure enough, I get home & try them... and they're simply A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT COOKIE. The look, the construction, the flav...

from CookieLoversWife

My husband cannot get enough of these! He had to start ordering these online because they are not available at our location. Always been his favorite.